(adapted from Chapter 3 of my forthcoming ebook, Fetish Uncensored, available November 2027)
Pivotal events, or triggers that spark fetish longing, have long been a favorite theory of how fetishes develop. So has the idea that fetishes are conditioned. In my experience, neither tells the whole story. Fetishes develop across a lifetime, not in a single moment or through a simple conditioned response. A pivotal event is more likely to reveal a desire than to create it.
The 1966 Boot Experiment
In 1966, Stanley Rachman published one of the most cited studies on whether fetishes are learned. He showed three men a slide of knee-length boots, followed each time by slides of nude women. After 24 to 65 pairings, all three showed genital arousal to the boots alone.
In retrospect, it was an odd, tiny study, more Pavlovian than sexological. His three subjects were young, unmarried psychologists who knew the experiment’s aim in advance. That makes a pretty weak foundation for any theory of fetish.
Rachman’s experiment did not create a fetish. It conditioned the subjects and created a lab response. Rachman suggested conditioning might explain some fetishes, but he warned against premature speculation about how fetishism begins. In 1968, Rachman and a colleague repeated the experiment with five men, then showed the boots without the nudes until the arousal stopped.
Where Fetishes Really Come From
While Rachman’s study showed us that people can make associations and get excited if an object or body part presages nudity, the experiment told us nothing about where fetishes really come from.
No study has shown that conditioning can create a true fetish. Rachman himself called his work a model. He titled his paper “Sexual Fetishism: An Experimental Analogue.” Two years later, he put “sexual fetishism” in quotation marks.
In my view, fetishes depend on evolving psychological and sociological circumstances.
My clinical experience from taking sexual histories of hundreds of fetishists is that people often recall telltale clues in childhood. Bondage fetishists may recall how enthusiastic they were about tying up “the bad guys” in their backyards. Others remember how much they loved playing with a parent’s footwear. As we pass through life stages, those early fascinations may turn into turn-ons for fetishists.
Henry’s Pivotal Event
Henry had a self-described spanking fetish. Being spanked occupied his imagination night and day, much to his dismay. He found himself continuously annoyed, bored, and otherwise uninterested in his engineering job. All he could think about was when he might find someone to spank him, whether he had enough to pay for a dom, or if he could find a free spanking somewhere. When he wasn’t mourning his lack of opportunity, he was watching and downloading more adult spanking porn than he would ever have time to watch.
Henry came to me for help getting his life together. He was failing at work; his house was a wreck and in need of many simple but critical repairs; his wife left him over his spanking fetish and told their kids about it, which cast a shadow over his relationship with them.
As I gathered his history with fetish desires, he told me that he knew where it all began.
“When I was about 12 years old, I saw my friend’s younger sister get spanked by her mother. It was like I was hit by lightning. Ever since then, I wanted to be spanked just like that, over a woman’s knee while people watched,” Henry told me. “There was a small crowd of kids watching with me. I’ll never forget it.”
What Henry’s Story Tells Us
Many people have come to my office remembering a single childhood event they believe turned them into fetishists. It’s a neat theory, but not how humans generally develop. Instead, I suspect something triggered them, revealing an underlying need that may have been there since early childhood. Henry believed this single event turned him into a fetishist.
Since he mentioned other kids in the room, I asked him, “So how many of the other kids do you think turned into spanking fetishists?”
That took him aback. “What?”
“Well, if seeing a spanking turned you into a fetishist, do you think everyone who saw it became a fetishist?”
“Well, shit.” He suddenly realized how unlikely that was. “I don’t know,” he said. “I guess not.”
I pointed out that one youngster might have been quietly appalled and swore never to spank their own kids, while another might see nothing unusual about a mom spanking her child. The spanking may have mesmerized Henry because it resonated with him viscerally. That day did not make Henry a fetishist. It revealed that he already was one.
Henry Finds His People
The revelation helped Henry to accept that his fetish was a fixture of his adult sexuality. He was ready to do something about it. I recommended he seek out forums and chat groups for his fetish. It didn’t take long for him to find his people in an online spanking community. People recommended mailing lists that included local spanking parties and kinky social events.
Gradually, he became comfortable enough at events to hook up with women willing to switch roles with him, so both could enjoy giving and receiving. He joined in the fun of spanking without shame or fear of rejection.
Step by step, Henry became calmer, more focused at work, less interested in porn, and more at peace with himself. But best of all, his kids wanted him in their lives and accepted him as he was. Their relationship grew stronger. We had completed our work together. Henry was in a good, safe space to explore his fantasies.
I have room for a couple of new clients right now. If your desires feel like they’re running your life, therapy can help you make peace with them and find your people. Contact me at gloriabrame.com/contact to book a session.
Blog Sources:
Photo credit: Andrea Piacquadio @Pexels




